For many Americans, a nativity scene represents one of the most touching and nostalgic aspects of Christmas. Whether it is a nativity scene near your fireplace or a full-size display at your local community center, these decorations help us get into the Christmas spirit. A nativity scene also reminds us of the religious significance of Christmas, and it helps us focus on the history of this holiday rather than the more consumerist elements of modern Christmas. But what happens if you or your community is threatened with a lawsuit for putting up a nativity scene? Believe it or not, this situation is becoming much more common than you might realize.
Why Do Communities Get Sued for Putting Up Nativity Scenes?
Communities and municipalities may be sued for putting up nativity reasons because of the United States' anti-discrimination laws. The general idea is that the government cannot fund displays that celebrate any particular religion, as this would be a form of discrimination against other religions that do not get displays. There is also concern over taxpayer money being used for religious projects when not all taxpayers follow that particular religion. This is essentially the age-old principle of the separation of church and state.
But is this really the way American laws work? According to a representative from the Thomas More Society, this is largely a misconception:
"Many erroneously assume that government entities are prohibited from allowing a religious display. The law is clear. Government entities may erect and maintain celebrations of the Christmas holiday – or allow citizens to do so on government property, including nativity scenes, as long as a crèche's sole purpose is not to promote its religious content, and it is placed in context with other symbols of the season as part of an effort to celebrate the public Christmas holiday through traditional symbols."
Nativity Scene Lawsuits Are Getting Out of Hand
Many lawsuits have been filed over nativity scenes in the United States over the years. One of the most controversial stories comes from Eureka Springs in Arkansas. This town municipality faces numerous threats of lawsuits but decided to keep their nativity scene anyway. Initially, the mayor seemed to cave in to pressure, announcing that the scene would be removed.
The town of Bucksport in Maine went the opposite direction, agreeing to remove their nativity scene after an atheist activist complained. The city officials were advised by their attorney to remove the nativity scene in order to avoid a lawsuit, and they quickly complied. This atheist requested that instead of a nativity scene, the town should put an image of Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Jefferson, and other Founding Fathers standing around a cradle. But instead of a baby Jesus in the cradle, the atheist wants to replace him with the Bill of Rights.
Another nativity scene was removed from a remote town in British Columbia, Canada after the mayor decided to ban the practice. This was the first time in decades that the town went without a nativity scene. A poll found that about 75% of town residents wanted the nativity scene to continue.